7 Reasons Why Your Website Looks Untrustworthy (And How to Fix It)

Website Design

90% of people base their decision on whether they want to work with you based on how trustworthy or professional looking your website is. So, how do you gain their business?

When you land on a bad page or website, what’s the first thing that influences your decision to stay or exit from the website? In most cases, it’s the trustworthiness of the website. This subjective feeling can highly impact whether a visitor will turn to a customer or not.” One factor that can impact your sales is website design.

The website design isn’t merely about visual appeal; it’s about creating a reputable online identity. Your website design forms the foundation for how visitors perceive your brand. It can motivate them to delve deeper into your content and interact with your business, thereby influencing conversion rates.

Let’s think about the problem of bad websites—those websites that repel users rather than attract them. They’re not just losing out on fleeting clicks; they’re potentially jeopardizing their entire business goals. Recognizing and rectifying these issues is vital for any organization aiming for online success. Let’s examine some common mistakes that can make a website seem untrustworthy and discuss strategies for turning these things around.

Reasons Why Your Website May Appear Untrustworthy

1. Poor Visual Appeal and Outdated Elements

When users arrive at your site, the initial element that captures their attention is its visual charm. The aesthetic quality of a website can significantly shape how users gauge a company’s credibility. An interface with bad website design or outdated elements can provoke visitors to doubt your business’s credibility . Let’s delve into how poor aesthetics and bad website design can impact user perception:

  1. Cheesy Stock Photos: Authenticity resonates with users. Generic or cliché stock images can give off a vibe that your brand lacks originality or sincerity. Instead, opt for high-quality, unique images that represent your brand and connect with your audience on a personal level.
  2. Excessive Use of Animated GIFs: While animations can be engaging overusing them distracts from the content and slows down page loading times, which can frustrate users and detract from your site’s professionalism.
  3. Cluttered Layouts: A layout crammed with too much information, too many colors, or an array of mismatched fonts can overwhelm visitors. This sensory overload makes it difficult for them to find what they need and may cause them to leave the site altogether.

How to Improve Your Website’s Visual Appeal

To address these issues and enhance your website’s perceived trustworthiness:

  • Embrace Simplicity: A clean, modern design not only looks professional but also improves usability. Space out your content into sections to avoid overwhelming the reader. .
  • Stay Current: Keep up-to-date with the latest web design trends and technologies. Regularly refresh your website’s look to avoid falling behind and appearing outdated.
  • Professional Touch: Be aware of your branding and font size. Invest in a professional web designer to ensure your website has a professional and cohesive look. 

Remember, first impressions matter greatly in the online world. Your website must instantly convey professionalism if you want to build trust with visitors. A well-designed website reflects positively on your brand and encourages users to engage further with your content.

2. Complicated or Confusing Navigation

When visitors land on your website, your goal is to help them find what they’re looking for. A well-structured navigation menu guides users to the information they’re looking for with ease.  In contrast, terrible websites frequently feature confusing navigation, which can leave even the most patient visitors feeling lost. This can ultimately lead to doubts with your company’s credibility.  

To prevent your site from being labeled as one with bad design or as outdated one, consider these practical suggestions:

  • Use Clear Labels: Instead of using technical terms or vague language, use simple and understandable words in your menu. This way, everyone will know where each link leads.
  • Organize Your Pages: Just like chapters in a book, group your pages into logical categories that go well together. Think about how you categorize your services or products and reflect that on your website. 
  • Highlight Important Pages: Not all pages are equally important. Arrange your navigation menu based on what users are most likely to look for, making sure those pages are easily accessible.

By making your website’s navigation simple and user-friendly, you create a welcoming online space that feels familiar and easy to explore—just like going back to your favorite café where the staff knows exactly what you want. This kind of environment builds trust and encourages people to spend more time engaging with your content.

3. Inconsistent Branding Elements: Is Your Design All Over the Place 

Have you ever come across terrible websites that seem all over the place? You’re not alone. Inconsistencies in design elements, such as colors, fonts, and images, can make visitors feel confused and lost. This experience can erode trust in your brand’s professionalism, creating a web of bad impressions that make users question the site’s legitimacy.

It’s like going to the dairy aisle of a supermarket but finding socks instead of butter and milk. Confusing, isn’t it? This is exactly how poor website design feels. Ensuring a consistent look and feel across your entire site is pivotal to establishing trust and familiarity amongst users. They should experience a sense of continuity as they navigate through different pages of your site.

The Importance of Consistency

Consistent design serves as an unseen guide that subtly communicates your brand values and persona. When your website aligns with your branding elements, it doesn’t just enhance user interaction—it also boosts conversions.

Implementing Branding Guidelines

To maintain consistency across your design elements, consider developing branding guidelines—think of it as a compass guiding all visual aspects of your brand. These guidelines typically outline:

  • The preferred color scheme: Save all hex codes of your brand colors
  • Typography standards: Have a set font used for headlines and paragraph text
  • Font size: Make sure the font size for headlines and text are consistent across the entire website.
  • Logo usage

Branding guidelines should be considered when  crafting your website, ensuring that every page  adheres to your brand identity.

By ensuring uniformity in your branding elements throughout the site, you ensure a more positive experience for your visitors. 

4. Lack of Trust Signals and Social Proof

When visitors come to your website, they want to see signs that it’s trustworthy. These are called trust signals, and they play a crucial role in building confidence. Think of it like choosing between two restaurants: one with lots of positive reviews and another with no feedback at all. It’s obvious which one you’d trust more.

If your website doesn’t have these trust signals, it may be seen as untrustworthy. People might wonder, “If others don’t trust this site, why should I?” That’s where social proof comes in handy – it’s like getting recommendations from friends. When potential customers see positive comments from satisfied buyers, it boosts your reputation.

Here are some practical ways to add trust signals without going overboard:

  1. Highlight Testimonials: Pick compelling stories from happy clients and put them at the very top of your website or next to buttons where people can take action.
  2. Display Security Badges: If you work with security companies or have certifications, show off badges on your site to let users know your credentials. 
  3. Feature Endorsements: Have any industry experts praised your work? Flaunt their endorsements proudly.

Make sure these elements blend well with your design instead of standing out awkwardly. You want everything to look cohesive while building trust at the same time.

A missing trust signal or lack of social proof could be the final piece of the puzzle for an otherwise professional website. By addressing this issue, you not only boost credibility but also create a better user experience overall.

5. Overly Intrusive Advertisements or Pop-ups

Picture this scenario: you’re engrossed in an article, and just as the narrative reaches a climax, a monstrous advertisement leaps onto your screen, obstructing your view. Infuriating, isn’t it? This is a prime illustration of how intrusive ads can negatively affect user experience on a bad website. They can easily distract from the main content of the website. 

Take into account these things to ensure a better user experience on your website. 

  • Balance is Crucial: Instead of bombarding visitors with pop-ups , utilize them purposefully . Ensure each pop up brings value and directly relates to the content your visitors are engaged with.
  • Relevance is Key: Verify that every advertisement on your site caters to your audience’s interests. Ads that gel with your content feel less like an interruption and more like a service.
  • Unobtrusive Lead Capture Techniques: Swap those aggressive pop-ups with something less disruptive like a contact form or a button linking to a contact formInline opt-in forms merge effortlessly with your content, allowing visitors to subscribe without being pressured to do so.

It’s important to be aware of a healthy balance between providing information and nudging a visitor to convert. Overly use of popups and ads can make visitors associate your website with spam, so be very purposeful with how you use them.  

6. Poor Responsiveness on Different Devices

Having a website design that doesn’t work well on mobile devices can make visitors doubt its reliability. Since a large portion of internet users access websites through their phones, ignoring mobile view is like  ignoring potential customers. Here’s what happens when users come across a website with poor responsiveness:

  1. Frustration Over Poor User Experience: Mobile visitors struggle to use pages that aren’t optimized for their screens. Having to pinch and zoom just to read text or navigate menus is annoying, and it can be the reason why users decide to leave and never come back.
  2. Doubts About Professionalism: A design that doesn’t adapt to different screen sizes can make the business seem unprofessional and uncaring towards user needs, which can harm the brand’s reputation.

To solve this problem, it’s essential to prioritize responsive design. Responsive web design ensures that your site looks good and works perfectly on all devices – whether it’s a computer, tablet, or phone. Here are the benefits of using responsive design:

  • Enhanced User Satisfaction: When users can easily use your website on any device, they’re more likely to stay longer and trust your site.
  • Increased Trust: Websites that appear well-designed and function smoothly on mobile devices are seen as more trustworthy and credible.

Remember, in today’s digital world, being mobile-friendly isn’t just an extra feature; it’s a crucial part of building trust with your audience.

7. Lack of Contact Information or Customer Support Options

When visitors land on a website, they often look for reassurance for immediate support or assistance.  Imagine browsing a site with no visible phone number, email address, or even a simple contact form. Red flags go up, right? This lack of basic contact information can make a website feel like a ghost town—unwelcoming and certainly untrustworthy.

Here’s why offering multiple channels for customer support isn’t just good manners; it’s good business:

  1. Credibility Booster: Displaying clear contact details signals to users that you’re open and accountable. It’s about showing potential clients that you are proactive 
  2. Customer Confidence: Knowing help is available at all times creates a safety net for users. It encourages them to take actions like purchasing or signing up since they feel secure in their ability to get support if they have any questions
  3. Feedback Loop: Providing contact options also means you value user feedback, which is crucial for improving your services and nurturing customer relationships.

Businesses should consider these strategies:

  • Visible Contact Details: Place your phone number or email in the header or footer—spots that visitors naturally check.
  • Support Page: Dedicate an entire page to support, with an FAQ section and various contact methods like live chat or a helpdesk.
  • Multiple Channels: Embrace diverse communication platforms. Some users prefer direct emails, others social media interactions, and some the immediacy of phone calls.

Remember, whether it’s through an elaborately designed contact page or a simple yet effective chat option, your goal is to diminish any doubts about your website’s authenticity. Every unanswered question due to unavailable customer support can lead to lost opportunities

Conclusion 

In the digital age, the credibility of your website is paramount in establishing trust and nurturing consumer relationships. Several elements can contribute to bad website design, such as poor visual appeal, complicated navigation, and inconsistent branding elements. These bad design examples can deter users from engaging with your site and therefore affect sales

Moreover, a lack of trust signals or social proof, overly intrusive advertisements or pop-ups, poor responsiveness on various devices, and insufficient contact information or customer support options are also culprits that fall under the category of web bad practices. All these factors can give off the impression of bad design, leading your site to be grouped among those terrible websites that don’t inspire trust.

Sustaining a trustworthy website transcends attractive aesthetics—it’s about offering a seamless user experience that reassures visitors of your company’s commitment and credibility. It involves avoiding bad designs by having a clear and user-friendly layout, consistent branding, visible and diverse methods for contact, and responsive design.

Every interaction a user has with your site is an opportunity to build faith in your brand. Therefore, it’s essential to ensure these interactions are positive by providing dependable customer support to address any queries or issues. Neglecting this aspect might result in missed opportunities 

Remember: An authentic and reliable website isn’t merely about preventing losses— it’s about forging meaningful connections with users that drive growth and success.

What is bad page design?

Bad page design, often synonymous with bad website design, refers to an unappealing or confusing layout that may deter visitors from interacting with your website. This can result from outdated elements, inconsistent branding, poor responsiveness on different devices, and overly intrusive advertisements.

What are examples of bad graphic design in websites?

Examples of bad graphic design in websites can include inappropriate use of fonts and colors, poor image quality, overcrowded elements, and lack of alignment or consistency. Such designs not only affect the overall aesthetic appeal but also lead to a confusing or complicated navigation experience for users.

How does bad designing affect my website?

Bad designing can significantly impact your website’s credibility. It gives off the impression that your site is “scammy” his can lead to a decrease in user engagement and potentially affect your site’s traffic and conversion rates.

How can I avoid bad design examples on my website?

Avoiding bad design examples involves ensuring a clear and user-friendly layout, consistent branding across all pages, visible contact methods, and a responsive design that works seamlessly on different devices. It’s also essential to provide dependable customer support to address any queries or issues promptly.

What happens if I neglect the bad aspects of my website design?

Neglecting the negative aspects of your website design could result in missed opportunities and can affect your company’s credibility.  Every interaction a user has with your site is an opportunity to build faith in your brand. Therefore, positive interactions are essential for forging meaningful connections that drive growth and success.

Scroll to Top